Welcome to the site !!
Did you match up the magnets when looking at the other one and note that they were in the same position in accordance with the keyway ??
I run the Flywheel Weight instead of the flywheel itself , but I know that in order to fire , the timing of the magnets has to be in the same position , (I also used the weight instead of the complete flywheel because it is less cost wise) , but the only thing I can think of is that the magnets are in a different position for some reason , and that is throwing the timing off , and that is why its not starting ...... did you buy direct from Steahly ?? , or thru a dealer ??? , as I am wondering if they gave you the wrong flywheel possibly ?? , but my suggestion is to call Steahly and explain to them the situation and what you did and noted , and give them the part # , so they can make sure it is either the correct part , and/or if they can send a replacement to swap out if it is possibly defective (it happens from time to time) , most reputable companies are willing to do things like that to make sure you are a happy customer (check my post about No-Toil Customer Service)
https://www.crfsonly.com/forum/viewtopi ... 41&t=43957 , and that your bike is running/working as it should ......
It sounds like you installed it correctly (used the correct Puller ,made sure the keyway was intact , etc.) , so they should not have a issue working with you to resolve the issue , unfortunately you will have to wait till Monday to call them , but at least you have the stock flywheel (and a 9 oz. ??) for now to get you thru the weekend .... and I agree , a flywheel/flywheel weight , is a major plus for off-road , but match up all (3 ?) of them and make sure the magnets are in the same location in accordance with the keyway , that will tell you if its the correct part at least .... also check for any rub marks on the stator to see if there was any clearance issue , as that will cause issues if its rubbing not only with it working correctly , but also with it damaging your stator , so you want to make sure it is not causing a issue , because if the coating gets wore off the windings and the copper wire becomes bare , it will short out the stator and then you will have another expense replacing that .....
